{
  "title": "Quantum-Gravity Consistency and Swampland: validity and failure map",
  "chapter": "Quantum-Gravity Consistency and Swampland",
  "kind": "validity-failure",
  "schematic": true,
  "not_to_scale": true,
  "stages": [
    "quantum-gravity premise and black holes",
    "charge, tower, and moduli constraints",
    "examples and conditional derivations",
    "counterexamples and dated tests",
    "typed consistency claim"
  ],
  "claims": [
    {
      "object": "no global symmetry",
      "required_declaration": "exact AdS/CFT or other stated premise",
      "diagnostic": "boundary current and bulk gauge check",
      "licensed_conclusion": "a conditional result in that framework",
      "unsupported_promotion": "an assumption-free theorem about all gravity"
    },
    {
      "object": "weak gravity or distance conjecture",
      "required_declaration": "charge normalization or moduli metric",
      "diagnostic": "extremality, towers, and examples",
      "licensed_conclusion": "a named conjectural constraint",
      "unsupported_promotion": "a proven universal inequality"
    },
    {
      "object": "de Sitter or landscape claim",
      "required_declaration": "compactification and EFT assumptions",
      "diagnostic": "controlled examples and counterexamples",
      "licensed_conclusion": "a dated conditional exclusion or obstruction",
      "unsupported_promotion": "settled absence of all vacua"
    }
  ],
  "takeaway": "No-global-symmetry results and swampland conjectures have different hypotheses and evidence; examples do not erase counterexamples or dates."
}